In the meantime of searching for the name of that song from the latest Twilight movie or Facebook stalking that guy or gal you recognize from class but can’t quite put your finger on from where, you might have found that suddenly—oh no, what is this?
The page is blocked? Their profile picture has been changed to “S-O-P-A”? In case you’ve lived under a rock in the Internet world called the ‘social network only’ section since October of last year, you may have scanned over an article heading complaining about two recent bills making their way through Congress involving SOPA and PIPA. Both bills allow corporations to shut down any website they have reason to suspect of being guilty of pirating their copywrited material, including any Youtube video, mp3 file, or even a blog post giving the link to a foreign torrenting website.
Uproaring disapproval from waves of Americans sending automated messages to district and state representatives, spreading awareness through blogs and social networks and openly protesting in groups stopped the progression of the bill last Friday, but was SOPA entirely bad? Clearly, the actors, directors, producers, and countless artists of pirated films, songs, and video games are the victims here. With a few mindful clicks amongst ads anyone can instantly download another’s precious work, robbing them of their well-earned riches while the average downloader saves a few bucks and the hassle of renting. There should be a law forbidding such downloading, but to what extent? As for the nonprofit websites such as Wikipedia, which could be instantly shut down if there were even a trace of illegal material such as a link to a downloading website within its millions of pages, they would be shown no mercy. While the creators of such websites have spent countless hours on these projects, Hollywood has lost millions. For the level of that mindless flash game you once could not pass but found the walkthrough for on Youtube, you would be considered a felon, and that scene from American Idol you missed but thankfully found as the most watched video of the day is an equal violation in the bill.
People’s responses to these bills have broken records and proven the fight against piracy will require a lot more give and take while considering how freely people use their at home computers. I’m sure we can all agree to some extent that there is a moral indecency to stocking up on your favorite movies and songs, but challenging the freedom of the internet will forever be a tricky business now that we’ve entered a new realm of globalization. At least now we can see that the starting point is the question of which matters more in the real world of politics: the compilation of an entire open sourced encyclopedia relied upon as the world’s largest means to free knowledge, or a loss of capital in the entertainment business? Money talks, my friend, and from here we will have to brace ourselves for a compromise.
CONNECT ON FACEBOOK